Local Futures

  • Home
  • Media room
  • Blog
  • Store
  • Contact

The Economics of Happiness

Donate
Menu
  • About us
    • Local Futures
    • Our team
    • Founder, Helena Norberg-Hodge
    • Get involved and support us
    • Our history
    • Close
  • Projects
    • Connect globally and locally
      • World Localization Day
      • Voices from the Field
      • Localization Action Guide
      • International Alliance for Localization
        • Join the IAL
        • IAL members
          • IAL member organizations
          • IAL Listserv
      • Ladakh Project
      • Planet Local
        • Culture
        • Eco Communities
        • Ecology
        • Health
        • Local Business & Finance
        • Local Energy
        • Local Food, Farming & Fisheries
        • Local Policy & Community Rights
        • Place-based Education
        • Sharing & Repairing
    • Gain a big picture perspective
      • Blog
      • Local Futures Podcast
        • Jeremy Lent: Shifting Paradigms
        • COP, carbon and high-tech: who is setting the agenda?
        • Beyond Conspiracy: Framing Meaningful Activism
        • Unpacking Global Empire from an Indigenous Perspective
        • More than Just the Vegetables
        • Food Sovereignty in the Global Economy
        • Transition, Tradition, and Trade
        • Not-for-Profit Businesses
        • Love, Values, and Wellbeing Economies
        • Growing a Farmers Market from the Ground Up
        • Beautiful Places: A Conversation with Wendell Berry
        • Creating the Framework for a New Economy
        • From GDP to GNH
        • Rebuilding Healthy Communities: The Growing Ecovillage Movement
        • Seeds of Resilience, Seeds of Sovereignty
        • Why Local Ownership Matters
        • Local Alternatives to Globalized Development: A View from India
        • How to Feed the World? A Political Agroecological Approach
        • Helena Norberg-Hodge on how corporate ‘free trade’ deals threaten local communities and economies worldwide
      • Webinars
        • Sacred Activism in a Post-Trump World Webinar
        • Talking Climate Webinar
        • People Power: Democracy and the Economy Webinar
        • Beyond Trump: The Path to Real Change Webinar
        • Bringing the Food Economy Home Webinar
        • A World Without ‘Free’ Trade: What it would look like and how to get there
        • Beyond ‘Free Trade’ – Alternatives to Corporate Rule
        • Education: Promises, Myths & Realities Webinar
        • Debt and Speculation in the Global Economy Webinar
        • A New Activism Webinar
        • Climate Change or System Change Webinar
        • Going Local Webinar
      • Powerful talks
      • The Economics of Happiness film
      • Films and short videos
      • Books and reports
    • Close
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
    • World Localization Day
    • Economics of Happiness conferences
    • Other past events
    • Close
  • Action resources
    • Getting the facts
      • Globalization – drivers and impacts
      • Localization – a solution-multiplier
      • Big Picture Activism – rethinking basic assumptions
    • Action tools
      • Localization Action Guide
      • Covid-19 response: let’s localize like never before
      • Maps of alternatives
      • Organizations for change
      • Independent media sources
      • Films for change
      • Recommended readings
    • Close
  • Books, reports & videos
    • Books and reports
      • Local is Our Future by Helena Norberg-Hodge
        • Endorsements for Local is Our Future
        • Translations of Local is Our Future
      • Ancient Futures by Helena Norberg-Hodge
      • Free reading materials
      • Annual reports
      • Translated resources
    • Films and short videos
      • PLANET LOCAL : A Quiet Revolution film
      • LOCAL: A Story of Hope short video
      • Local Food Can Save The World short video
      • Going Local: the solution-multiplier animation
      • Insane Trade short video and factsheet
        • Insane Trade! & factsheet translated
      • The Economics of Happiness film
      • Ancient Futures film
      • Planet Local short film series
        • 1 – Introduction: The new local food movement
        • 2 – Diverse farming systems
        • 3 – Local food webs: Exploring systems of distribution
        • 4 – Local food processors: AKA making delicious food
        • 5 – Challenges & solutions
        • 6 – Ecovillages & networks for new farmers
        • 7 – and finally… Here’s a little more inspiration
    • Close
You are here: Home / Localization / Small Loans, Big Problems: The False Promise of Microfinance

Small Loans, Big Problems: The False Promise of Microfinance

June 17, 2015 by Helena Norberg-Hodge 8 Comments

Plantation workerEver since Bill Clinton and the World Bank enthusiastically embraced the microfinance concept in the 1990s, we at Local Futures have been skeptical of its benefits, seeing it as part of a whole package of “market solutions” to our social and environmental crises that, in the long run, make things much worse. We have pointed out that these loans often target rural populations who were not previously in debt: they represent the long arm of capitalism reaching into remote rural areas, encouraging a shift away from dependence on the land and the local community, towards competition in a resource-depleting global economy.

It has not been easy to oppose micro-credit: many well-intentioned grassroots activists have bought into the idea that giving ‘Third World’ women a loan would eradicate poverty and reduce population. This thinking was promoted with missionary zeal, and spread rapidly across the world. In trying to counter it, we have often felt like heretics. (One of the most difficult moments was when I was asked to debate Muhammad Yunus, the founder of the Grameen Bank, at the height of his popularity, on BBC radio.)

For this reason we’re very happy to see this article by Jason Hickel, a professor of anthropology at the London School of Economics, in the UK Guardian: The microfinance delusion: who really wins? As Hickel says, “microfinance usually makes poverty worse”, because the vast majority of microfinance loans are used to fund the purchase of consumer goods that the borrowers simply can’t afford: “they end up taking out new loans to repay the old ones, wrapping themselves in layers of debt.” Even when used to finance a small business, the most likely outcome is that the new businesses fail, which leads to “vicious cycles of over-indebtedness that drive borrowers even further into poverty.” The only winners are the lenders, many of whom charge exorbitant interest rates. Hickel concludes that “microfinance has become a socially acceptable mechanism for extracting wealth and resources from poor people.”

We would argue that there are other winners in what Hickel calls “the microfinance game”. Corporate interests of all stripes have a vested interest in seeing millions of people drawn more deeply into the debt-based globalized money economy. Interestingly, at the bottom of the webpage where Hickel’s article appears there are links to articles sponsored by the credit card giant Visa, all of them urging more “financial inclusion” in the global South – in other words, bringing more people into the economic system that corporate interests like Visa dominate. “Helping the world’s one billion unbanked women” turns out to be about how “more than 200 million women lack access to a mobile phone, meaning they’re excluded from digital banking opportunities.” Another article argues that one of the greatest challenges facing policymakers involves “providing some 2.5 billion people with access to formal financial services.”

This is propaganda, pure and simple: it is part of a drumbeat coming from think-tanks and corporate-friendly pundits that have been very effective in convincing people – including well-meaning philanthropists and activists – that the solution to global poverty requires pulling ever more people into the global economic system. That system is failing the majority even in the “wealthy” countries, while spurring rampant consumerism and unsustainable resource use worldwide.

The solutions to our many crises – including poverty – will not come from a global marketplace rigged by de-regulatory trade treaties to favor the biggest multinational corporations. They depend on preventing further deregulation of global corporations, while shifting towards more localized economies in which people can have real control over their own lives.

 

Photo credit: “Plantation Worker,” Luxor, Egypt, by Ryan Stuchly

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Related

A Tribute to Eduardo Galeano
We are all Greece

Filed Under: Localization, Resistance and Renewal Tagged With: banking, community, corporate, corporations, culture, development, economics, globalization, microfinance, women

Author: Helena Norberg-Hodge

Helena Norberg-Hodge is founder and director of Local Futures/ISEC. A pioneer of the “new economy” movement, she has been promoting an economics of personal, social and ecological well-being for over 40 years. She is the producer and co-director of the award-winning documentary 'The Economics of Happiness', and is the author of 'Local is Our Future' and 'Ancient Futures: Learning from Ladakh'. She was honored with the Right Livelihood Award for her groundbreaking work in Ladakh, and received the 2012 Goi Peace Prize for contributing to “the revitalization of cultural and biological diversity, and the strengthening of local communities and economies worldwide.”

Comments

  1. Thomas Pichon says

    June 24, 2015 at 3:27 pm

    Thanks for this great article Helena, I agree with your convictions. With this micro-finance system, we only replicate the western model on a smaller scale: the entrepreneurs are pushed to generate revenues in order to pay back, inevitably eroding the sense of community and creating individualism. The intention is good, but in reality, other ways of development should be favored, such as what has been done via The Ladakh Project.

    Reply
  2. Yareli Arizmendi says

    August 2, 2015 at 4:22 am

    Question from the urban jungle: After reading We Are All Greece a question persists: Why are we paying taxes to a government that only uses them to pay private entities to run what should be publicly owned institutions ie. Prisons, deportation centers. Public money for private profit is the latest laugh of corporations, who are now individuals, and a lackey government that does their bidding. Is there any value in organizing a tax freeze – a ‘not with our money’ movement? And Thank you for your valuable work!

    Reply
  3. Leslie Sklair says

    January 16, 2016 at 11:01 pm

    This is very thought-provoking and it is good to find out about all those people who are genuinely facing up to problems in ways that are generally ignored by the mass media. However, in my opinion, the two biggest obstacles to creating a new and better society are not clearly enough brought to the surface. First, I would argue that it is not globalization per se but capitalist globalization that is the main problem, most of the contributions appear to suggest that global capitalism can somehow be transformed into a more caring capitalism though all the evidence seems against this conclusion. Second, the assumption seems to be that more state regulation would curb the worst excesses of capitalist globalization – again the evidence suggests not. The conclusions I would draw are that it is not more economic growth we need but degrowth, and that we have to create new forms of social organization that free us from the capitalist market, the hierarchic state. We have to start thinking about what comes after capitalism and statism.

    Reply
  4. emergency loans nz says

    January 9, 2017 at 5:03 pm

    It has not been easy to oppose micro-credit: many well-intentioned grassroots activists have bought into the idea that giving ‘Third World’ women a loan would eradicate poverty and reduce population.

    Reply
  5. Factor Loads Factoring says

    April 19, 2018 at 3:19 pm

    Thanks for sharing this. There are still a lot of things that we should be aware of, particularly in the business world.

    Reply
  6. Nova Cash Flow Finance says

    May 4, 2018 at 10:47 am

    This is a mind-blowing and well – written article. I think it is important to know things like this. I learned a lot from this. Looking forward to more posts like this.

    Reply
  7. Nova Business says

    December 27, 2018 at 10:09 am

    Thanks for sharing this article. I think that small loans will definitely be a great problems because some may tend to get several of it and didn’t able to repay. I believe that it is one of the reason why we suffer financially.

    Reply
  8. Debtor Finance says

    May 10, 2019 at 9:40 am

    This article is very interesting. I think that this article will open up the mind of the readers. I also think that poverty or financial crisis is a very serious issue that the world is facing now. I hope that it will be fix or will have a solution for it as soon as possible. Thanks for sharing this article.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy

Subscribe to the Economics of Happiness Blog

Sign up for our email updates

Latest Blogs

  • Of George Monbiot, mathematical modernism and the case for agrarian localism

    August 3, 20221 Comment
  • The Gospel of Progress

    July 20, 2022No Comments
  • Lurching from food crisis to food crisis

    July 8, 2022No Comments
  • The food shortage solution in your backyard

    June 15, 20221 Comment
  • Supply chain failures: another reason for localized economies

    June 8, 20221 Comment
  • The dirty truth about clean energy

    May 25, 20229 Comments

Blog posts by Category

  • Capitalism (10)
  • Cities (2)
  • Climate Change (54)
  • Community (32)
  • Consumerism (6)
  • Coronavirus (19)
  • Democracy (4)
  • Development (24)
  • Economic Growth and Degrowth (34)
  • Economics of Happiness Conferences (4)
  • Education (9)
  • Energy (3)
  • Environment (45)
  • Food and Farming (71)
  • Free Trade and Globalization (45)
  • Happiness (5)
  • Health (27)
  • Indigenous worldview (16)
  • Inequality (7)
  • Inner transformation (16)
  • Livelihoods and jobs (38)
  • Local energy (9)
  • Local finance (5)
  • Local food (14)
  • Localization (56)
  • Nature (6)
  • New economy (20)
  • Resistance and Renewal (18)
  • Technology (38)
  • The Economics of Happiness (17)
  • Transportation (2)
  • Uncategorized (4)
  • War (2)

Local Futures Logo
About us
Contact
Get involved
Privacy policy

Projects
The Economics of Happiness film
Events
Action resources
Books, reports and videos
Blog
Store

Sign up for our email update

Donate

Local Futures © Copyright 2022 | site by digiflip
 

Loading Comments...