Local Futures

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Store
  • Contact
  • Sign up
  • Donate

The Economics of Happiness

Menu
  • About us
    • Local Futures
    • Our team
    • Founder, Helena Norberg-Hodge
    • Get involved
    • Media room
    • Our history
    • Close
  • Projects
    • Connect globally and locally
      • World Localization Day
      • Voices from the Field
      • Localization Action Guide
      • International Alliance for Localization
        • Join the IAL
        • IAL members
          • IAL member organizations
          • IAL Listserv
      • Ladakh Project
      • Planet Local
        • Culture
        • Eco Communities
        • Ecology
        • Health
        • Local Business & Finance
        • Local Energy
        • Local Food, Farming & Fisheries
        • Local Policy & Community Rights
        • Place-based Education
        • Sharing & Repairing
    • Gain a big picture perspective
      • Blog
      • Local Futures Podcast
        • Iain McGilchrist – Rediscovering Wisdom in a World Gone Mad
        • Charles Eisenstein – Towards a New and Ancient Culture
        • Vandana Shiva – The Power of People
        • Mental Health in the Global Economy with Gabor Maté
        • Jeremy Lent: Shifting Paradigms
        • COP, carbon and high-tech: who is setting the agenda?
        • Beyond Conspiracy: Framing Meaningful Activism
        • Unpacking Global Empire from an Indigenous Perspective
        • More than Just the Vegetables
        • Food Sovereignty in the Global Economy
        • Transition, Tradition, and Trade
        • Not-for-Profit Businesses
        • Love, Values, and Wellbeing Economies
        • Growing a Farmers Market from the Ground Up
        • Beautiful Places: A Conversation with Wendell Berry
        • Creating the Framework for a New Economy
        • From GDP to GNH
        • Rebuilding Healthy Communities: The Growing Ecovillage Movement
        • Seeds of Resilience, Seeds of Sovereignty
        • Why Local Ownership Matters
        • Local Alternatives to Globalized Development: A View from India
        • How to Feed the World? A Political Agroecological Approach
        • Helena Norberg-Hodge on how corporate ‘free trade’ deals threaten local communities and economies worldwide
      • Webinars
        • Sacred Activism in a Post-Trump World Webinar
        • Talking Climate Webinar
        • People Power: Democracy and the Economy Webinar
        • Beyond Trump: The Path to Real Change Webinar
        • Bringing the Food Economy Home Webinar
        • A World Without ‘Free’ Trade: What it would look like and how to get there
        • Beyond ‘Free Trade’ – Alternatives to Corporate Rule
        • Education: Promises, Myths & Realities Webinar
        • Debt and Speculation in the Global Economy Webinar
        • A New Activism Webinar
        • Climate Change or System Change Webinar
        • Going Local Webinar
      • Powerful talks
      • Films and short videos
      • Books and reports
    • Close
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
    • Planet Local Summit Bristol 2023
    • World Localization Day
    • Economics of Happiness conferences
    • Other past events
    • Close
  • Action resources
    • Getting the facts
      • Globalization – drivers and impacts
      • Localization – a solution-multiplier
      • Big Picture Activism – rethinking basic assumptions
    • Action tools
      • Localization Action Guide
      • Covid-19 response: let’s localize like never before
      • Maps of alternatives
      • Organizations for change
      • Independent media sources
      • Films for change
      • Recommended readings
    • Close
  • Books, reports & videos
    • Books and reports
      • Life After Progress
      • Local is Our Future
      • Ancient Futures
      • Free reads
      • Translated resources
      • Annual report
    • Films and short videos
      • PLANET LOCAL : A Quiet Revolution
      • LOCAL: A Story of Hope
      • Local Food Can Save The World
      • Going Local: the solution-multiplier
      • Insane Trade!
      • The Economics of Happiness
      • Ancient Futures
    • Close
You are here: Home / Climate Change / Clean energy won’t save us – only a new economic system can

Clean energy won’t save us – only a new economic system can

September 29, 2016 by Jason Hickel 4 Comments

Earlier this year media outlets around the world announced that February had broken global temperature records by a shocking amount. March broke all the records too. In June, our screens were covered with surreal images of flooding in Paris, the Seine bursting its banks and flowing into the streets. In London, floods sent water pouring into the tube system right in the heart of Covent Garden. Roads in south-east London became rivers two meters deep.

With such extreme events becoming more commonplace, few deny climate change any longer. Finally, a consensus is crystallizing around one all-important fact: fossil fuels are killing us. We need to switch to clean energy, and fast.

This growing awareness about the dangers of fossil fuels represents a crucial shift in our consciousness. But I can’t help but fear we’ve missed the point. As important as clean energy might be, the science is clear: it won’t save us from climate change.

Let’s imagine, just for argument’s sake, that we are able to get off fossil fuels and switch to 100 percent clean energy. There is no question this would be a vital step in the right direction, but even this best-case scenario wouldn’t be enough to avert climate catastrophe.

Why? Because the burning of fossil fuels only accounts for about 70 percent of all anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions. The remaining 30 percent comes from a number of causes. Deforestation is a big one. So is industrial agriculture, which degrades the soils to the point where they leach CO2. Then there’s industrial livestock farming which produces 90 million tons of methane per year and most of the world’s anthropogenic nitrous oxide. Both of these gases are vastly more potent than CO2 when it comes to global warming. Livestock farming alone contributes more to global warming than all the cars, trains, planes and ships in the world. Industrial production of cement, steel, and plastic forms another major source of greenhouse gases, and then there are our landfills, which pump out huge amounts of methane – 16% of the world’s total.

When it comes to climate change, the problem is not just the type of energy we are using, it’s what we’re doing with it. What would we do with 100% clean energy? Exactly what we are doing with fossil fuels: raze more forests, build more meat farms, expand industrial agriculture, produce more cement, and fill more landfill sites, all of which will pump deadly amounts of greenhouse gas into the air. We will do these things because our economic system demands endless compound growth, and for some reason we have not thought to question this.

Think of it this way. That 30 percent chunk of greenhouse gases that comes from non-fossil fuel sources isn’t static. It is adding more to the atmosphere each year. Scientists project that our tropical forests will be completely destroyed by 2050, releasing a 200-billion-ton carbon bomb into the air. The world’s topsoils could be depleted within just 60 years, releasing more still. Emissions from the cement industry are growing at more than 9% per year. And our landfills are multiplying at an eye-watering pace: by 2100 we will be producing 11 million tons of solid waste per day, three times more than we do now. Switching to clean energy will do nothing to slow this down.

The climate movement made an enormous mistake. We focused all our attention on fossil fuels, when we should have been pointing to something much deeper: the basic logic of our economic operating system. After all, we’re only using fossil fuels in the first place to fuel the broader imperative of GDP growth.

The root problem is the fact that our economic system demands ever-increasing levels of extraction, production and consumption. Our politicians tell us that we need to keep the global economy growing at more than 3% each year – the minimum necessary for large firms to make aggregate profits. That means every 20 years we need to double the size of the global economy – double the cars, double the fishing, double the mining, double the McFlurries and double the iPads. And then double them again over the next 20 years from their already doubled state.

Our more optimistic pundits claim that technological innovations will help us to de-couple economic growth from material throughput. But sadly there is no evidence that this is happening. Global material extraction and consumption has grown by 94% since 1980, and is still going up. Current projections show that by 2040 we will more than double the world’s shipping miles, air miles, and trucking miles – along with all the material stuff that those vehicles transport – almost exactly in keeping with the rate of GDP growth.

Clean energy, important as it is, won’t save us from this nightmare. But rethinking our economic system might. GDP growth has been sold to us as the only way to create a better world. But we now have robust evidence that it doesn’t make us any happier, it doesn’t reduce poverty, and its “externalities” produce all sorts of social ills: debt, overwork, inequality, and climate change. We need to abandon GDP growth as our primary measure of progress, and we need to do this immediately – as part and parcel of the climate agreement that will be ratified in Morocco later this year.

It’s time to pour our creative power into imagining a new global economy – one that maximizes human well-being while actively shrinking our ecological footprint. This is not an impossible task. A number of countries have already managed to achieve high levels of human development with very low levels of consumption. In fact Daniel O’Neill, an economist at the University of Leeds, has demonstrated that even material de-growth is not incompatible with high levels of human well-being.

Our focus on fossil fuels has lulled us into thinking we can continue with the status quo so long as we switch to clean energy, but this is a dangerously simplistic assumption. If we want to stave off the coming crisis, we need to confront its underlying cause.


This article originally appeared in The Guardian.

Photo: Wesley Armstrong on Unsplash 

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Related

Changing Everything
Regenerative Agriculture: our best shot at cooling the planet?

Filed Under: Climate Change Tagged With: agriculture, climate change, corporations, deforestation, economic growth, economics, GDP, growth imperative, happiness, neweconomy, sustainability

Author: Jason Hickel

Jason Hickel is an anthropologist at the London School of Economics. He specializes in globalization, finance, democracy, violence, and ritual, and is the author of "Democracy as Death: The Moral Order of Anti-Liberal Politics in South Africa".

Comments

  1. Andrea Morison says

    September 29, 2016 at 2:51 pm

    Absolutely agree. I am working to stop the largest infrastructure project in Canada right now – the Site C dam. It is also the most destructive project ever assessed through Canada’s environmental assessment process.
    I realize that we are not just battling a dam, rather we are battling the value system of the majority – that being the desire to accumulate ‘stuff’.
    GDP growth could still be achieved through alternative means. One example is by valuing experiences, particularly those not far from home. There are many more opportunities as well.
    Hopefully more people will become aware of the need to make this significant change in our thinking – soon!

    Reply
    • Paul Burt says

      October 1, 2016 at 9:01 am

      Our thinking and then our acting must change. We can start changing our personal actions now. We have a choice. Do we/you have the will?

      Reply
  2. Paul says

    October 10, 2016 at 11:57 pm

    If we deal with the economic system without dealing with psychopathy (which results in unchecked exploitative and corrupt leadership in commerce and politics) then we’ll soon arrive back to the same situation. Both need addressing right now to minimise the effects of the current collapse of life on our planet.

    Reply
  3. noha tarek says

    March 30, 2020 at 1:59 pm

    This article is amazing… & I’d add that it’s not just the economic system that we need to change, but even on a broader scale our whole way of thinking, perceiving, & acting in the world as humans, from a perspective of a cosmic community, that is based on a network of equally-valued subjects or creatures, rather than a hierarchical order of power. Getting rid of the ritual of resource accumulation from the drive of fear & desire to self-survive, & instead, living with enough to meet our basic needs in the present, along with a network of communal solidarity.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy

Subscribe to the Economics of Happiness Blog

Sign up for our email updates

Latest Blogs

  • Why we must abolish the Energy Charter Treaty

    January 27, 20231 Comment
  • Humility and the myth of limitlessness

    January 12, 20231 Comment
  • Hin Lad Nai: A Successful Model of Indigenous Resistance

    January 4, 20234 Comments
  • Ecological Economics

    December 21, 20221 Comment
  • Chak Chok: a campaign against junk food

    December 14, 20222 Comments
  • Low-tech solutions

    November 30, 20223 Comments

Blog posts by Category

  • Capitalism (10)
  • Cities (4)
  • Climate Change (60)
  • Community (34)
  • Consumerism (6)
  • Coronavirus (19)
  • Corporate power (3)
  • Democracy (4)
  • Development (24)
  • Economic Growth and Degrowth (35)
  • Economics (1)
  • Economics of Happiness Conferences (4)
  • Education (9)
  • Energy (6)
  • Environment (47)
  • Food and Farming (80)
  • Free Trade and Globalization (47)
  • Happiness (6)
  • Health (30)
  • Indigenous worldview (19)
  • Inequality (8)
  • Inner transformation (17)
  • Livelihoods and jobs (39)
  • Local energy (9)
  • Local finance (6)
  • Local food (21)
  • Localization (57)
  • Nature (6)
  • New economy (20)
  • Resistance and Renewal (20)
  • Technology (42)
  • The Economics of Happiness (17)
  • Transportation (2)
  • Uncategorized (4)
  • War (2)

Local Futures logo

About us
Contact
Blog
Store
Annual report
Privacy policy

Sign up to our newsletter

Donate

Local Futures © Copyright 2023 | site by digiflip
 

Loading Comments...